Author, Book review, Fiction, Ireland, Katharine Weber, literary fiction, New York, Publisher, Setting

‘The Music Lesson’ by Katharine Weber


Fiction – paperback; Phoenix; 162 pages; 1999.

The Music Lesson is the second novel by American writer Katharine Weber, who, in 1996, was named one of the 50 Best Young American Novelists by Granta. She has since gone on to write two other critically acclaimed novels, the latest of which — Triangle — is on the long list for the International IMPAC Dublin Literary Award. Which is a roundabout way of saying, she’s got some kudos in the book world.

At just 162 pages in length, The Music Lesson is an almost perfectly formed — and quick-to-read — novel that tells the story of Patricia Dolan’s unwitting involvement in an IRA splinter group known as the (completely fictional) Irish Republican Liberation Organisation (IRLO). But it’s also a story about 17th-century Dutch art and the murky world of Irish-American identity.

The narrator is a 41-year-old librarian who works at the Frick Collection, an art museum in New York. She’s lonely, bored and still grieving over the break-up of her marriage and the death of her daughter in a traffic accident. She’s close to her father, a retired policeman of Irish extraction, and has grown up with a notion of her Irishness, although she’s never set foot in her “homeland”.

One day she receives a phone call from a man with an Irish accent introducing himself as her cousin, Michael O’Driscoll. Curious, because “he sounded young” and envisioning a “student with a knapsack, run away from university, seeking his fortune in America”, she promptly invites him for lunch.

On the way to the restaurant, Michael O’Driscoll told me to call him Mickey, and by the second corner we had sorted through the O’Driscolls and figured how it was that we were related. Strangely enough, right up to that moment, it had never occurred to me in any real way that I had
contemporary relations in Ireland. Which is really odd, now that I think about it, given all the passion about Irish politics in my family. It has had something to do with grandfather Paddy’s being so cut off from his parents only a short couple of generations out of Ireland.

The meeting with Mickey changes Patricia’s life. She embarks on a sordid affair with him. And then, just weeks into the relationship, finds herself acting as a kind of unpaid consultant to the IRLO theft of a valuable Vermeer painting, The Music Lesson, owned by Queen Elizabeth II.

It is only when Patricia is holed up in a lonely cottage in West Cork “babysitting” the stolen goods that she begins to question her involvement in the plot. Later, when things don’t go according to plan, she also questions her relationship with Mickey and whether her sense of “Irishness” has been totally misplaced…

Told in diary form from Patricia’s perspective, The Music Room is not a straightforward narrative. It often loops back on itself and information is withheld from the reader, so that you’re never entirely sure whether Patricia is as calculating as her co-conspirators or whether she’s simply a naive pawn in their game.

For the most part, it’s a gentle, lolling novel, perhaps mirroring the beauty of the rural countryside Patricia finds herself living in. There are lovely passages about art, especially Vermeer’s paintings, which convey a real passion for the subject matter. But there’s also a delicious undercurrent of potential terror and violence. When you begin to realise exactly what it is that Patricia has got herself caught up in you do, in fact, fear for her safety.

Ultimately, The Music Lesson is a powerful read, a bitter twisted love story gone wrong, written in rich, evocative prose that absorbed me from the first page to the last. If this novel is any indication of Katharine Weber’s talents, then it’s time I tracked down her other work and got lost in those stories too.

4 thoughts on “‘The Music Lesson’ by Katharine Weber”

  1. Katharine Weber came to our Book and Author Luncheon last June 2007. She was a wondeerful speaker and explained what she did in heer latest book Triangle. The Music Lesson introduced me to her and blew me away when I read it. Read Triangle you’ll love it!


  2. I “ran into” Katharine Weber for the first time when, in researching for my historical novel, Odessa, Odessa, I read Triangle. I was impressed with her writing and storytelling and made a mental note to look up other books. It was only recently, after a friend read a review of my book that mentioned Triangle and suggested that I read The Music Lesson, that I fulfilled my intention of reading more of Weber’s work. I was not disappointed! She writes with understated passion and knowledge of her subject and keeps you turning the page until the end. I read it in one sitting. And loved it.


    1. Thanks for your comment, Barbara. I haven’t read anything else by Weber since writing this post more than 14 years ago! It’s a nice reminder that I should hunt out her work. I will look up Odessa, Odessa.


I'd love to know what you think, so please leave a comment below

Fill in your details below or click an icon to log in: Logo

You are commenting using your account. Log Out /  Change )

Facebook photo

You are commenting using your Facebook account. Log Out /  Change )

Connecting to %s

This site uses Akismet to reduce spam. Learn how your comment data is processed.