‘Out of a Clear Sky’ by Sally Hinchcliffe


Fiction – paperback; Pan Books; 295 pages; 2008. 

Sally Hinchcliffe’s debut novel Out of a Clear Sky has already drawn comparisons to Barbara Vine, so I can’t claim to be original by stating the same. Yet the quiet build-up of tension and the psychological drama that plays out is hugely reminiscent of Ms Vine’s best work. It also has shades of Nicci French, mainly in its depiction of a single young woman on the run from a disturbed man.

And yet there’s something about Out of a Clear Sky that is wholly original.

The story is set in the world of bird-watching (or “twitching” as it is colloquially known) with each chapter headed by the name of a bird species — kingfisher, firecrest, wren — espousing on the theme. This continues with lovely descriptions of wild birds and the places in which they inhabit, giving the story a languid kind of beauty, almost a hymn to the natural world.

But belying this sense of calm is a tension that builds and builds, as the narrator Manda comes to terms with the realisation that a fellow birdwatcher, the mysterious and slightly spooky David, is observing her in much the same way as Manda observes the birds — closely and with much patience. Having just broken up with Gareth, her long-term boyfriend, Manda is already feeling pretty fragile, not helped by the lack of support shown by her small circle of friends who have seemingly abandoned her.

As the narrative progresses, and Manda shuts herself away by going on more solo birdwatching trips, we get glimpses of her troubled childhood in Africa and the inexplicable death of her mother. These flashbacks are seamlessly woven into the main storyline, so the reader is almost unaware of the subtle shifting backwards and forwards in time. But what you do begin to appreciate is that Manda has always been a victim and that history seems to be repeating itself. Will she find the energy and the will to keep on fighting, or will she succumb to a loner’s morbid fascination?

Despite a slightly weak circular plot (I guessed the major twist at the end long before I reached it), Out of a Clear Sky is a quietly thrilling read, and I’ll look forward to reading more by this talented writer in the future.

9 thoughts on “‘Out of a Clear Sky’ by Sally Hinchcliffe

  1. It’s slightly different and a little bit menacing, but I really enjoyed it. It’s on the three-for-two tables at Waterstone’s at the moment, if you want to hunt it out.


  2. The novel “has drawn comparisons to Barbara Vine”. Has it drawn any comparisons with Ruth Rendell yet?


  3. Funny, I’ve read a lot of Ruth Rendell, but no Barbara Vine, I guess because Ruth Rendell’s books are always thinner. I admit I was trying to catch you with that comment, but you knew they were the same person. My favorite Ruth Rendell is “The Water’s Lovely” which I listened to on CD.


  4. Aha, I’m the opposite: read several Vine but no Rendell! She has a detached kind of voice, which makes for a quietly menacing read. I’ve enjoyed “Grasshopper” and “The Blood Doctor”.


  5. Have been sent a review copy by the very kind publisher, so now all I have to do is make time to read it! (Then write the review.) Thanks again for the tip.


I'd love to know what you think, so please leave a comment below

Fill in your details below or click an icon to log in:

WordPress.com Logo

You are commenting using your WordPress.com account. Log Out /  Change )

Google photo

You are commenting using your Google account. Log Out /  Change )

Twitter picture

You are commenting using your Twitter account. Log Out /  Change )

Facebook photo

You are commenting using your Facebook account. Log Out /  Change )

Connecting to %s

This site uses Akismet to reduce spam. Learn how your comment data is processed.