Author, Book review, crime/thriller, Fiction, Ireland, Penguin, Publisher, Setting, Tana French

‘In the Woods’ by Tana French


Fiction – paperback; Penguin; 464 pages; 2008.

When I first picked up In the Woods by Tana French at JFK airport on my last trip to New York last October I envisaged it would tread similar territory to Edna O’Brien’s dark, claustrophobic In the Forest. After all, they’re both Irish crime books by Irish writers (who, in my opinion, even look alike, almost as if they are mother and daughter) with much the same titles, but that’s where the similarities end.

In the Woods lacks the literary flourishes that made O’Brien’s book somewhat difficult to read; instead you get a completely absorbing, rocket-fuelled narrative that zips along at Formula One pace. I read this in about two days while on a recent trip to Ireland and found myself thinking about the storyline long after I’d finished the book and repacked it in my suitcase.

Police procedural set in Dublin

The story, a police procedural, is told from the perspective of Rob Ryan, a detective on the Dublin Murder Squad (which, by the way, does not exist in real life), who has a secret past that only his immediate family knows about.

When he was a young boy he was playing with two friends in the local woods, but when dusk arrived none of them returned for their evening meal and a search party was organised. Rob was found clinging to a tree with blood-filled shoes, so traumatised by whatever had happened to him and his friends that he was unable to recall a single detail. His friends were never found, and 20 years on, Rob is still unable to remember what happened.

This troubled history comes rushing to the fore, when Rob and his colleague, Cassie Maddox, are assigned a murder investigation involving a 12-year-old girl whose body is found near the very same woods from Rob’s childhood. Are the crimes linked? Could the perpetrator be the same person responsible for the disappearance of Rob’s friends?

This is the crux of this superbly realistic debut novel — and to say anything more would ruin the plot for those who have not yet read it.

No neat ending

What I liked most about this book is that it doesn’t come with a neat, well-rounded conclusion, which makes the story seem even more authentic, because how many murder investigations have neat, well-rounded conclusions?

It makes you think, makes you fill in the gaps, makes you come up with your own theories and I cannot understand those readers who think they’ve been short-changed by this — and judging by the reviews of Amazon there’s quite a few.

My only quibble — and it’s a relatively minor one in the grand scheme of things — is the “voice” of Rob Ryan, which didn’t seem authentically male to me, but perhaps that was a deliberate device to explain why he got on so well with his female counterpart. In fact, I couldn’t quite work out how I felt about their platonic, almost sibling-like relationship, because as much as it provided additional depth to the storyline, at other times it came across as slightly too cloying. Had neither of these characters discovered the concept of “me time”, I wondered.

In the Woods recently won the Mystery Writers of America’s Edgar Award for Best First Novel, and I’m not surprised. It’s an astonishingly well written book by a first time author, one that grips you from various different angles: will Rob’s secret be discovered; will he have a nervous breakdown from the emotional, psychological stress of the investigation; what happened to his missing friends that fateful day in 1984; and what happened to the girl who was murdered more recently? There’s so many red herrings and dodgy clues, it’s impossible to guess the outcome.

And the period details — of Ireland in 1984 and the vastly different New Ireland (before the very recent collapse of the Celtic Tiger) in 2004 — make the story seem particularly believable.

I was surprised by how much I enjoyed this one, and will eagerly eat up her next one, The Likeness, which is lying in wait on my bedside table…

5 thoughts on “‘In the Woods’ by Tana French”

  1. I really enjoyed this one as well. I thought Rob’s character was really interesting, though I’m always drawn to first person narratives–it makes me wonder what they’re not sharing with the reader. I was sort of glad there wasn’t a nice, tidy ending as well, but it’s hard not to wonder just what really happened in those woods. I’m wondering if she somehow ties it all together in a later novel since she seems to be working with the same characters in different stories. I’ve just ordered her next book, since it is finally out in paper.


  2. Good point about first person narratives and not knowing what they’re not telling us. I thought Rob was a surprisingly well-adjusted character, despite what had happened to him in his childhood, and yet I wasn’t convinced that he was male, he sounded more female to me. Funny how that happens.


  3. I was also a fan of this one! I have to say that I enjoyed The Likeness even more, although be prepared for it to be very different from In The Woods. Same excellent writing though!


  4. I enjoyed this one as well, and was suprised by how many people seemed bothered that Rob’s story wasn’t neatly tied up. As you say, in reality so many cases go unsolved , especially when it comes to children who disappear.
    I think The Likeness is as good, and liked Cassie’s voice better than Rob’s. The premise is a bit unlikely though!


  5. I am really enjoying this book so far. It is very interesting what some people have to say about Rob not sounding more feminine. I agree and disagree. I’m in the middle of the book, and one thing I find strange is his relationship to Rosalind. The way he talks about her to me sounds like he is attracted to her which is a little weird considering the age difference, but his behavior towards her can be described as very “motherly”. That is just how I felt about it when I read the parts he had with her.


I'd love to know what you think, so please leave a comment below

Fill in your details below or click an icon to log in: Logo

You are commenting using your account. Log Out /  Change )

Twitter picture

You are commenting using your Twitter account. Log Out /  Change )

Facebook photo

You are commenting using your Facebook account. Log Out /  Change )

Connecting to %s

This site uses Akismet to reduce spam. Learn how your comment data is processed.