Triple Choice Tuesday

Triple Choice Tuesday: Guy Savage

Triple-Choice-TuesdayWelcome to Triple Choice Tuesday. This is where I ask some of my favourite bloggers, writers and readers to share the names of three books that mean a lot to them. The idea is that it might raise the profile of certain books and introduce you to new titles, new authors and new bloggers.

Today’s guest is Guy Savage from His Futile Preoccupations.

Guy, who is British but lives in America, has a terrific blog jam-packed with wonderful reviews, mainly of classics — Russian, French and English from the 19th century — crime and noir fiction.

“Books have always been a consolation and an escape for me,” he states on his About page. “I can remember learning to read, and I still feel a thrill when I disappear into a new book and realise that I’m engaged in reading something wonderful, something I’ll always remember. I cannot imagine a life without books.”

Without further ado, here’s Guy’s Triple Choice Tuesday selections:

Cousin-Bette A favourite book: Cousin Bette by Honore Balzac

There are so many books I could slot into this category, but I’m going to choose one I think about a great deal. It just happens to be written by one of my favourite authors — Balzac.

Cousin Bette is a tale of a spinster who’s the poor relation of the wealthy Parisian Hulot family. This novel is a great favourite for Balzac’s approach to the complications and murky depths of human behaviour. It illustrates the timelessness of human behaviour, and how easy it is to destroy a human being if you are ready to exploit their weaknesses.

Balzac understood human nature so well, and here he is at the top of his game as he explores the complicated emotions that swirl inside Bette’s head. Since the Hulots are her benefactors, it’s assumed that she is grateful to them, but instead she nurses hate and secretly swears to destroy them all. Just how she does this is the substance of this superb novel. The key to the destruction of the Hulots is found in their personal weaknesses, so Bette doesn’t really have to ‘do’ a lot to lead the family into destruction. She’s there at key moments and she helps arrange key incidents, but basically the Hulots open the door to their destruction.

One of the things that intrigues me so much about this novel (it’s one of my favourite Balzac novels, by the way) is the way in which all the kindnesses directed towards Bette are taken by her as insulting and degrading. As readers, it’s fairly easy for us to see that, logically, without the Hulots she’d be in dire circumstances, but at the same time, it’s also easy for the nasty side in each of us (come on, admit it’s there) to understand exactly how Bette feels with each cast-off, with each paltry acknowledgment, and with each assumption that a hideous suitor is ‘good’ enough for her.

She isn’t an equal and she knows that she never will be. She may have food and clothing, but none of this is free, and in return she is supposed to be devoted to making the lives of the Hulots smoother. She despises Baroness Hulot and realises that if fate had turned one way instead of another, she could have been a baroness instead of the poor relation who’s expected to be happy with the crumbs from everyone else’s table.

“Envy remained like a germ plague which may come to life and devastate a city if the fatal bale of wool in which it lies hidden is ever opened.”

Dark-City A book that changed my world: Dark City: The Lost World of Film Noir by Eddie Muller

There are many books (and films) which served as signposts at various points in my life, but I’m narrowing it down to one. In 2004, I read an article in the newspaper announcing the 2nd Annual Noir City Film Festival organised by the Film Noir Foundation. I read the lineup and rued the fact that I was unable to go. I was busy chafing against my lot in life when I said, “damn it, I’ll have my own festival.”

I didn’t know much about film noir at the time, and like most people, I was familiar with some of the more ubiquitous titles in the genre (Double Indemnity, The Postman Always Rings Twice, etc). So reading that Eddie Muller was the person responsible for putting the film festival together, I ordered a copy of his marvellous book Dark City: The Lost World of Film Noir — along with a selection of a number of the films to be shown at the film festival.

The book is incredible. Muller has a fresh, lively and evocative style that meshes perfectly with the subject matter, and I recommend the book to anyone who wants to get jump-started with noir. Well, after reading the book (and drooling over the fabulous photos) the result was that I fell in love with noir, and gradually — well, to be honest, not so gradually — it consumed and obsessed me. Noir is described by some experts as a genre; others say it’s a style, and while I’m not arguing with either of those positions, for me: noir is a state of mind.

When I read Dark City: The Lost World of Film Noir, everything slotted into place: the way I felt about life, man’s struggle in society, and the immutability of human behaviour. It was as if noir had been there all this time hiding in some dark, forgotten corner…waiting for me to discover its dark, bleak nihilistic core. Since 2004, there’s been no looking back, and the love affair with noir continues.

In 2007, I became a fairly regular contributor to the Film Noir of the Week blog, and in 2010, I began contributing to the Film Noir Foundation’s e-newsletter, The Sentinel.

Matter-of-life-and-sex A book that deserves a wider audience: A Matter of Life and Sex by Oscar Moore

This was an easy choice. While I’m putting this under the selection “A book that deserves a wider audience”, by its subject matter, the book, unfortunately narrows itself. This is a beautiful, poignant, graphic, gut-wrenching and tragic tale of a young man named Hugo (14 when the book begins), who slides into a sordid life of prostitution, pornography and drugs. The drugs begin as fun but inevitably become the seemingly protective yet ultimately self-destructive sheath with which Hugo deals with his vulnerability.

Hugo becomes mired in an ugly life before he has the maturity to understand his actions, and then by the time he does mature, he is irrevocably damaged. Hugo has no moral compass, no barriers, no reason to put on the brakes, and if you read the book, you commit to Hugo’s journey to hell.

This is an immensely powerful book — and at its conclusion, I felt traumatized by its sheer, raw emotional power. Dark & bleak, this harrowing tale was the only novel written by journalist Oscar Moore, who died of AIDS in 1996 at age 36. If Oscar Moore had lived, he would have been a major contributor to British fiction, and this incredible novel stands as a testament to the loss of his tremendous talent:

“It wasn’t that he felt guilty. Hugo had never noticed a conscience. If he had one, it was rarely awake. The flicker in his eye in the mirror in the lift wasn’t an accusation. It was a signal. A flash. A half-smile. Tentative, to himself. He couldn’t indulge it because then he’d laugh, and the laugh wouldn’t come, or cry, and no tears would happen. He just stared back as if he’d never seen himself before. He just stared at himself and, with a slight intake of breath, stepped out of the lift, down the beige carpet corridors and knocked on another painted door with three gilt numbers.”

Thanks, Guy, for taking part in my Triple Choice Tuesday!

I’m particularly intrigued by the Balzac and the Moore.

What do you think of Guy’s choices? Have you read any of these books?

13 thoughts on “Triple Choice Tuesday: Guy Savage”

  1. Cousin Bette is one of the few books I dissected during English Lit studies that I didn’t end up hating (somehow the process of pulling apart every nuance of a novel usually makes them lose their magic for me). The Moore sounds interesting but I’d have to choose the right time to read it, a journey to someone else’s hell doesn’t always appeal.


  2. What a wonderful selection have read other Balzac books ,the other two are totally new to me ,and both look great ,Ive not look at guy’s blog will do now ,thanks Kim as ever a wonerful insight into a blogger ,all the best stu


  3. It’s always a pleasure to read Guy’s blog, and as a fellow fan of Balzac I’m looking forward to Cousin Bette. (I’m (sort of) working my way through La Comedie Humaine in the order recommended). But what really interests me about your choices is the Film Noir idea, as in, I can’t go so I’ll have my own festival, because this happens to me every year. What I’d really like is a book as good as your Noir one sounds, but about French cinema instead so that I can have my own French film festival, perhaps with croissants and champagne served at interval. Any suggestions?
    PS Kim, love having TCT back, thanks!


  4. There’s a book called French Cinema from its beginnings to the Present by Remi Fournier Lanzoni. That’s the one I’d recommend. Then I’d see what I could rent in terms of some of the big names:
    Claude Sautet
    Luis Bunuel (which is cheating but who cares)
    Claude Chabrol
    Eric Rohmer (one of my all-time favourites)
    Sacha Guitry
    Jean Vigo (a must-see)
    Benoit Jacquot
    Cedric Klapisch
    André Téchiné
    Patrice Leconte
    Claude Lelouch
    Betrand Tavernier
    Louis Malle
    Claude Miller
    Marcel Ophuls
    Pitof’s Vidocq
    Jean Renoir
    Alain Resnais
    Francois Ozon
    Catherine Breillat
    Abel Gance
    Jacques Becker
    Jean-Pierre Melville
    Claude Berri
    Now I’m getting excited.
    I don’t like French New Wave, and there are lots of other names that have historic importance (lumiere), but these are some of my favs. I know I’ve forgotten some.
    Thanks Kimbofo for the article.


  5. Great to see this feature back and Guy was an excellent choice. I not only enjoy his blog (because he reads extensively a lot of fiction which I prefer to explore much more selectively so I need the points), he has also become Mrs. KfC and my main source for recommendations on DVD detective television series, one of our more obscure weaknesses. The Italian series on Inspector Montalbano (set in Sicily) ranks with the best television I have ever viewed and I had never heard of it until Guy recommended it. And since Camilleri writes a complete novel for each show, I now have 20+ crime novels on the agenda, as a follow-up.


  6. Have missed this feature so I’ll join the chorus. And Guy’s selection is pretty much what I would expect from him … it’s strange but I seem to like much of the same “stuff” (as in ideas) that Guy does, but we rarely cross paths in the actual books we read.
    Oh, and as one who tends to be drawn to gut-wrenching books I was fascinated by the Moore when I started reading the description, and then the excerpt clinched it. Great writing. I love that little word “beige” inserted in the midst of it.


  7. I know next to nothing about French film, but if you’re putting together a personal Festival then I’m going to butt in and suggest Theodore Dreyer’s 1928 silent Passion of Joan of Arc, an outstanding and beautiful film — all fissured faces against stark white walls, Joan’s head sitting in the frame like a decapitated and solid suffering boulder while the inquisitors glare down their crow-beak noses and fall into diagonal compositions, and the best Burning scene of all the Joans I’ve seen (one of the channels here had a Joan of Arc marathon on Sunday so I’ve seen her burnt a few times and Dreyer gets top marks. Bresson wasn’t bad. Bottom marks go to Victor Fleming, who kept cutting to one of the male characters giving a speech while Ingrid Bergman went up in flames).


  8. TCT is great.
    I’ll be buying the noir book. I love noir but wasn’t sure which book on it to get – there’s lots of them and many are good so it’s hard to make a choice without a recommendation.
    Getting a recommend for a book on French cinema in the comments is the icing on the (probably ultimately expensive) cake.


I'd love to know what you think, so please leave a comment below

Fill in your details below or click an icon to log in: Logo

You are commenting using your account. Log Out /  Change )

Twitter picture

You are commenting using your Twitter account. Log Out /  Change )

Facebook photo

You are commenting using your Facebook account. Log Out /  Change )

Connecting to %s

This site uses Akismet to reduce spam. Learn how your comment data is processed.