Abacus, Author, Book review, England, Fiction, Hong Kong, Jane Gardam, literary fiction, Malaya, Publisher, Setting

‘Old Filth’ by Jane Gardam


Fiction – paperback; Abacus; 260 pages; 2009.

First published in 2004 and shortlisted for the Orange Prize in 2005, Jane Gardam’s Old Filth is one of those novels that is a delight to read from start to finish.

The central subject — a rich old man reflecting on his life in the judiciary — might seem rather staid and dull, but in Gardam’s hands it is a moving and often witty portrait of a complex and hugely interesting character.

The old man is Sir Edward Feathers, who is also known as Eddie, the Judge, Fevvers, Teddy and Old Filth. The latter is an acronym for Failed In London Try Hong Kong.

Edward was born in India during the glory days of the British Empire — his father, Captain Feathers, was the District Officer of Kotakinakulu Province in Malaya. Sadly, Edward’s mother dies a few days after giving birth, so he is left in the care of his father, an indifferent, emotionally cold man mired in grief (and later alcohol), who pays him little attention. By the time he is four-and-a-half, Edward is a wild child, speaks fluent Mandalay and has the run of the jungle neighbourhood. But tradition dictates that he must go Home — to England — to be educated and to spare him the risk of childhood diseases.

This sets in motion a pattern that repeats itself throughout the rest of his life: wrenched from the people and places he has come to love, and thrust into new, frightening situations in which he is forever the outsider looking in. Or, as he states later on, “always to be left and forgotten”.

But despite the legacy of what can only be described as a rather cruel childhood — on arrival in England he is placed in a foster home, where the care is dubious, and at school his stammer and close friendship with another boy makes him a target for bullies and gossips — he becomes a successful advocate and judge in Hong Kong.

When the book opens, Edward is nearing eighty and living alone in Dorset, to where he and his recently deceased wife, Betty, had retired. The story interleaves his present existence — ageing rapidly, becoming forgetful and doddery — with stories of his past, including his troubled teenage years, near death on a boat headed to the Far East, and his time protecting Queen Mary during the Second World War.

What becomes apparent as Edward’s story unfolds is that his outward appearance — the distinguished career and privileged lifestyle — hides an emotionally scarred man who believes his life is bereft of meaning. And much of that is to do with the fact that Edward has no children upon which to pass his legacy.

Indeed, there’s a telling scene in which the elderly Edward tells a young woman that he and Betty never wanted children. “It was deliberate,” he says. And then, in a startling confession, he adds:

“Think carefully before you bring children into the world. Betty and I were what is called ‘Empire orphans’. We were handed over to foster parents at four or five and didn’t see our parents for at least four years. We had bad luck. Betty’s forster parents didn’t like her and mine — my father hadn’t taken advice — were chosen because they were cheap. If you’ve not been loved as a child, you don’t know how to love a child. You need prior knowledge. You can inflict pain through ignorance. I was not loved from the age of four and a half. Think of being a parent like that.”

While the novel is pervaded by a gentle melancholy, Gardam also throws in highly comic moments to lighten the mood. The humour largely works by having Edward do crazy things — such as driving rather dangerously and capturing the attention of the police — or behaving badly —  being rude to his servants — without him quite realising that he is in the wrong.

On the whole Old Filth is a richly textured novel, one that is vivid, funny and strangely moving.

15 thoughts on “‘Old Filth’ by Jane Gardam”

  1. I read this pre-blog and remember really enjoying it – I think I had a lot of sympathy for Filth and long-suffering wife Betty. Looking foward to reading ‘The Man with the Wooden Hat’ which tells of their earlier years.


  2. I’m looking forward to “The Man With the Wooden Hat”, too, which is told through Betty’s eyes (I think). Actually, I think Betty was a bit of a goer, so it’ll be great fun to find out what she was like when she was younger.


  3. I hadn’t expected to like it, but I’d heard so many great things about it that when I saw it in a charity shop for £2 I figured it was worth the risk. I really need to read more books by Gardam; she has a rather extensive back catalogue.


  4. I read The Tambourine Queen a few years ago and loved it. I’ve been saving Jane Gardem novels since then, not reading them all right away so I’ll have them to look forward to over the coming years. I think I’ll read one ever three years just to make sure I don’t run out.


  5. I hadn’t expected to like it either. I mean, the title is rather off-putting, isn’t it? But now I am waiting for her back catalogue to come out in e-book and I can assure you that as soon as these become available I am going to read a lot more by Jane Gardam. She is quite a discovery as far as I am concerned.


  6. I have always mulled over Jane Gardam. I think, though I could have mixed this up, that my Gran is a real fan of her work and has read a few of her books for her book groups. These are ones she hasnt begrudged too much so I am assuming they were good ones lol.


  7. I am really looking forward to reading this book! I’ve only heard wonderful things about it, and you know I have a fondness for clever female authors, which I have every reason to believe Jane Gardam absolutely is! Do you think you’ll read the follow-up to this, The Man in the Wooden Hat?


  8. Yes, will definitely read the follow-up. Indeed, I am really keen to read all of Gardams back catalogue. She seems to be one of those writers that doesnt get the attention she deserves — or maybe I am just ignorant and havent seen that many reviews of her books on blogs.


  9. I read one of Gardam’s short stories recently (I think it was shortlisted for the Nat Short Story Prize). It sounds like the story involved the same characters. Anyway, I really loved it, and got Old Filth as a result. I want to read it more than ever now!


  10. I wouldn’t say it features very much at all. Basically, it’s where Edward and Betty live, but most of the story focuses on Hong Kong, Malaya and London.


  11. I read this book last year and was enchanted by Edward Feathers. He was a successfull man who had this hidden and lonely life behind him. The second book, The man in the wooden hat, casts a closer look at Edward and Betty’s meeting and marriage. Gardam makes these two characters believable and as a reader she makes you want the best outcome. Feathers is one of my favourtie fictional characters.


  12. Edward made me laugh a lot — Im not sure he realised he was a bit ridiculous in his old age. He reminded me of a chap I know, actually, who has staff and always moans about them. The fact Edward couldnt remember the name of his cleaner, even though shed been in his employ for decades, was quite funny, dont you think?
    Glad to hear that The Man in the Wooden Hat is good. I am greatly looking forward to reading it at some point.


I'd love to know what you think, so please leave a comment below

Fill in your details below or click an icon to log in:

WordPress.com Logo

You are commenting using your WordPress.com account. Log Out /  Change )

Google photo

You are commenting using your Google account. Log Out /  Change )

Twitter picture

You are commenting using your Twitter account. Log Out /  Change )

Facebook photo

You are commenting using your Facebook account. Log Out /  Change )

Connecting to %s

This site uses Akismet to reduce spam. Learn how your comment data is processed.