Fiction – Kindle edition; Magabala Books; 356 pages; 2020.
Julie Janson’s Benevolence tells the story of the early days of European settlement in Australia but with one important twist: it’s told through the eyes of a young Aboriginal girl.
Written as a rebuttal to Kate Grenville’s The Secret River*, a novel that dared to talk about frontier violence from a white perspective, Janson uses a First Nations lens to tell the other side of the story.
The author, who is a Burruberongal woman of the Darug Nation, says it is a work of fiction but is based on historical events in and around the Hawkesbury River in Western Sydney.
In her afterword, she says:
The characters are derived from Darug, Gundungurra and Wonnaruah Aboriginal people who defended their lands, culture and society. Muraging is based on my great-great-grandmother, Mary Ann Thomas, who was a servant on colonial estates in the Hawkesbury area. The other characters in the novel are inspired by historical figures and my imagination, except the governors who are based on historical documents.
Raised by white settlers
Benevolence spans 26 years (1816 to 1846) in the life of Muraging (later renamed Mary), who finds herself caught between two cultures.
Raised and educated by white settlers at a boarding school set up for Aboriginal children, she desperately misses her family and for most of this novel, she swings between the two: working as a servant when she needs food and shelter, heading on country to be with her people when she needs to get back in touch with her culture and traditions.
But even when she is with her own kind she stands out, for she wears European, albeit servant, clothes, can play the violin (she totes one around with her) and speaks English. In white society, the colour of her skin marks her out as different and her pretty looks attract the unwanted attention of often violent men. No matter where she is, she is “othered” and her desire to fit in is only made harder by the children she bears (with white men) and must raise on her own.
But this is not just a tale about one indigenous woman’s experience, it’s a larger tale about the frontier wars, which rage on in the background, and of the violence committed on First Nations people by white settlers determined to keep the land for themselves, declaring Australia terra nullius and treating the original inhabitants as nothing more than vermin to be shot and exterminated.
From the start, Mary is aware of the danger that white men pose to her race because she has heard the rumours circulate at school:
Days go by and Mary hears other children’s stories whispered in the night. Many have seen, and still see, the bodies of their parents shot and hung on trees with corn cobs in their mouths. They still watch in horror as crows peck out living eyes and black beaks pick brains.
Later, as an adult, she knows about the Bells Falls Gorge massacre, north of Bathurst, in which women and children jumped to their deaths after white settlers opened fire on them — and she is terrified she could be caught up in something similar.
She’s also increasingly aware of the destruction white people are causing and the implications this poses for local tribes. When she’s on country, for instance, the women in her tribe struggle to gather enough food to eat because “the white hunters have massacred all the local kangaroos” and there is little game nearby. The new settlers are also wreaking havoc in other ways:
The men discuss the thousands of newcomers arriving in ships in Sydney Town and how they crash through the bush smashing the fragile undergrowth, cutting down the oldest, tallest and most sacred trees – even carved burial trees. Log-splitting men follow the axe men and the sound is deafening, night and day. Fiery pits burn all night with wasted bark. Her peoples’ footpaths have become bullock tracks with deep greasy mud churned by huge wagons full of logs. The tiny fruits and flowers are being crushed. Nothing is left of the forest’s ceremonial sites. Their stories cannot be told if the places and sites of the ancestors are gone. The waterholes are ruined by cattle and the goona-filled water cannot be drunk.
Throughout the story, we see how Mary’s Christian upbringing — supposedly designed to deliver her from sin — simply entraps her. It’s a feeling that never quite goes away, messes with her sense of identity and makes her reliant on white settlers who don’t always have her best interests at heart.
An important novel
Benevolence is an important book because it puts a human face to an Aboriginal perspective, a perspective that has previously been ignored or written out of history.
At times, I felt it lost momentum, perhaps because it is just so detailed, covering every aspect of Mary’s life, which includes time on the run in the bush, various jobs as a servant, a lusty romance with a white reverend and a short stint in jail. But on the whole, it’s a comprehensive account of all the many challenges and tragedies to which Mary must bear witness.
For another take on this novel, please see Lisa’s review at ANZLitLovers and Sue’s at Whispering Gums.
* The Secret River is based on Grenville’s ancestor Soloman Wiseman, a Thames waterman who was transported to Australia for theft, and who later settled on the Hawkesbury River at the area now known as Wisemans Ferry. He is mentioned in Benevolence as follows:
Wiseman’s Ferry is a large raft where loads of flour are winched across the river by a metal wheel driven by a horse. The old ferryman and innkeeper is Solomon Wiseman. His inn is called The Sign of the Packet; he is an ex-convict and lighterman from the Thames in London. Along the riverbank, the convict road workers are dressed in torn, dirty shirts, their skins tanned from the sun and hunger etched on their faces.
This is my 7th book for #20booksofsummer 2022 edition. I bought it in July 2020, began reading it and then got distracted by covid lockdown shenanigans and never returned to it. I also read it this year as part of my project to read more books by First Nations writers. You can see all the books reviewed as part of this project on my dedicated First Nations Writers page.
14 thoughts on “‘Benevolence’ by Julie Janson”
Thanks for the mention!
I loved the way she satirised the conventions… I’m looking forward to whatever she writes next.
Agreed. I found it a hard book to review though. I had so many THOUGHTS.
LikeLiked by 1 person
Yes, a good book will do that!
Yes, I reviewed this book too. I loved the word play on the title – so biting. It’s good seeing these First Nations historical novels coming out alongside contemporary fiction.
Ah, must remember to hunt out your link!
LikeLiked by 1 person
This looks an interesting and worthwhile read. It’s not however, as far as I can find out, yet released in England.
Hi Margaret, according to Amazon it will be released in the UK in hardback on 22 September, because it’s available for preorder. It’s already available as an ebook because that’s where I purchased my copy.
The Secret River was crying out for an Indigenous take. I’m glad it has been done. The only Indigenous historical fiction I’ve read to date have been Kim Scott’s That Deadman Dance and Benang. I might have missed Sue’s and Lisa’s reviews but I can see I must read Benevolence – I’ll be interested to see what difference an Indigenous POV makes compared with the earlier work of Eleanor Dark and Thea Astley.
It’s refreshing to see an indigenous perspective on early European settlement.
I bought this on Kindle the instant you said it was an Indigenous rebuttal of The Secret River. I really enjoyed the first part of Grenville’s novel but was frustrated by the Australian part and the lack of agency Grenville gave the Indigenous characters, alongside her apparent lack of curiosity about them.
Reading these books back to back would certainly be an interesting exercise. I loved The Secret River when I read it all those years ago but I was pretty ignorant about First Nations issues at the time and I could now see if I read it again I might have some problems with it. To Grenville’s credit, she did start an important conversation…
LikeLiked by 1 person
This has been on my radar ever since the Claudia Karven book program last year…now I just have to find time to read it !
Oh yes, I forgot that was mentioned on the show!
LikeLiked by 1 person