Anna George, Australia, Author, AWW2016, Book review, crime/thriller, Fiction, literary fiction, Penguin Australia, Publisher, Reading Australia 2016, Setting

‘What Came Before’ by Anna George

What came before by Anna George

Fiction – paperback; Penguin; 255 pages; 2014.

‘My name is David James Forrester. I’m a solicitor. Tonight, at 6.10, I killed my wife. This is my statement.’

So begins Anna George’s debut novel, What Became Before, a dark and disturbing look at a marriage that goes completely off the rails set in Melbourne’s inner-west.

The book charts the two-year relationship between Elle Nolan, a former lawyer turned successful film maker, who is independent and lives alone, and David Forrester, a solicitor caught in a well-paying job that he hates.

When they meet Elle is in her mid-30s, David is 42. Both are a different points in their lives and careers, and seem almost complete opposites, but there’s a spark between them which they flame into something stronger.

When they initially get together the sex is electric, so much so that Elle shelves her original idea that their union was to be a simple one-night stand. Before she knows it, David has practically moved in to her home in Seddon, a Western suburb that he hates and she loves, and spend every spare moment together. Happiness forever after beckons.

But, as one would expect from a novel that starts out with such a dark and intriguing opening line, things start to go a bit awry. When Elle first notices David’s tendency to be immature and spiteful, she dismisses it, thinking she can change him. But when that behaviour escalates to violence, she breaks it off with him.

Yet David is a tenacious man — and won’t let her go. Over the course of two years, the pair have more break-ups than you can poke a stick at, but they always end up back together again — until that one crucial night when David attacks her in the kitchen and ends her life.

A deeply unsettling read

Admittedly, I wasn’t sure about this novel when I began it. I thought the characters were slightly pretentious and I found the constant descriptions of sex in the opening chapters a little off-putting. But there’s something about What Came Before that worms itself into your brain, so much so that whenever I put it down because I had to go to work or do chores or whatever, I found myself itching to pick it up again.

And the characters got under my skin, to the point that I couldn’t shake them off even after I’d finished the book feeling exhausted and drained. Now, almost a week down the line, I’m still thinking about their peculiar, but probably more common than we realise, relationship and wishing I could have stepped in and helped them sort it out.

One of the greatest strengths of the novel is its unusual structure. It’s written in the third person, but the author writes from both character’s perspectives and intertwines their narratives so it’s hard to separate one from the other (a bit like their relationship): David’s narrative focuses on the night he murders his wife and sees his future life unspool before him, while Elle’s is told retrospectively as she hovers over her lifeless body and recalls the story of their relationship from beginning to end.

The prose style is often short, clipped, fast-paced. But it’s also rather stylish in places and feels slick and contemporary.  The author is very good at capturing that feeling of being in love — romantic love and limerance are recurring themes — and of the give and take required to make a relationship work. And the characterisation is superb: you might not like either Elle or David but they feel real and all-too human.

All in all,  What Came Before is a dark, atmospheric and gripping read, one that brims with suspense and depicts the true horror of an abusive relationship with great sensitivity and insight. It’s full of twists and turns and dotted with little shocks, which gradually become more and more unsettling, but this isn’t your usual run-of-the-mill psychological thriller. There’s something greater at play here, and perhaps the secret lies in the author’s afterword, where she states:

It took me over a decade to write What Came Before. During that time, I read countless news stories of women killed by their partners or exes. I’d like to acknowledge those women, as well as the women and children I’ve alluded to in this book, whose lives were so devastatingly cut short.

This is my sixth book for #ReadingAustralia2016 and my fourth for #AWW2016.

This book is currently only available in ebook format in the US. It has not been published in the UK but can be ordered from the with free worldwide delivery.

8 thoughts on “‘What Came Before’ by Anna George”

  1. Sounds like a powerful and disturbing read – I’m thankful for the author’s note you quote, though. I have an irrational Thing against books narrated or from the POV of someone who’s dead at the beginning of the book, and I won’t be reading it, I’m fairly sure, but I’m enjoying this showcase of Australian writing that is starting to build up in all its variety!


    1. Thanks, Liz, I admit that I felt uneasy about the dead person narrator but it works in this novel, mainly because she doesn’t keep alluding to her death: it’s the story of her life.

      And yes, the variety of Australian literature is pretty wide-ranging. I wouldn’t have embarked on this project if I thought all the books would be more of the same. I’m an eclectic reader, albeit with a preference for dark, disturbing reads, and I knew the 120+ Australian books on my shelves were relatively diverse. I suspect I may, however, be surprised at just how diverse they really are when I come to the end of the year!

      Liked by 1 person

  2. I loved this book! I think it showed great skill in conveying the creeping toxic effect of domestic abuse combined with the sharp psychological thriller theme. It stayed with me after I finished reading it.


    1. Yes, that’s a really god description of the book. It shows how easy it is to fall into these relationships yet convince yourself that everything’s OK. Elle is a smart woman yet she still finds it difficult to break up with David because she loves/needs him. I liked the psychological thriller aspect, too, and the way the author slowly builds up the suspense so it becomes a terrifying page turner yet never takes it into unconvincing territory.

      Liked by 1 person

I'd love to know what you think, so please leave a comment below

Fill in your details below or click an icon to log in: Logo

You are commenting using your account. Log Out /  Change )

Twitter picture

You are commenting using your Twitter account. Log Out /  Change )

Facebook photo

You are commenting using your Facebook account. Log Out /  Change )

Connecting to %s

This site uses Akismet to reduce spam. Learn how your comment data is processed.