Good things come in threes, they say.
Here are three eclectic stories, all focused on women characters and written by women writers, that I have read this year. All are highly recommended.
They include a narrative non-fiction book by Australia’s queen of historical true crime, a best-selling novel from Korea and an award-winning new release set in Western Australia.
They have been reviewed in alphabetical order by author’s surname.
‘The Killing Streets: Uncovering Australia’s first serial murderer’ by Tanya Bretherton
Fiction – paperback; Hachette Australia; 352 pages; 2020. Review copy courtesy of the publisher.
Tanya Bretherton has made a name for herself in Australia as a writer of historical true crime. I have previously read The Suitcase Baby and have The Suicide Bride in my TBR. The Killing Streets is her latest.
It examines, in painstaking detail, a series of violent murders against women in Sydney in the early 1930s. It took a while for the police to cotton on, but eventually, the cases, in which the women’s bodies were found dumped in public places, were linked together and suddenly the hunt was on for Australia’s first serial killer.
Unfortunately, in their rush to convict someone, the police made many mistakes and got the wrong man: the killings continued regardless.
As well as being a fascinating account of (unreliable) police investigative techniques at the time, this book is also an eye-opening portrait of a misogynistic society in which women were merely the playthings of men and if they went missing or were killed it was their fault for being in the wrong place at the wrong time, wearing the “wrong” kinds of clothing, pursuing the “wrong” kind of career or simply belonging to the “wrong” class. This is very much a story of a society in which victim-blaming was king, where the police were quick to rush to judgement and where media coverage and hearsay had an entire city gripped by fear.
The Killing Streets is a thoroughly researched and highly readable example of narrative non-fiction that puts a series of Depression-era crimes into a social, historical and economic context. It gets a bit bogged down by detail in places and sometimes the creative elements of the narrative felt overdone, taking away from the reportage of the story, but on the whole this is a good one for true crime fans.
‘Kim Ji-young, Born 1982’ by Cho Nam-ju
Fiction – paperback; Simon & Schuster; 176 pages; 2020. Translated from the Korean by Jamie Chang.
This international bestseller from Korea, first published in 2016 but recently reissued, is a damning portrait of a contemporary society that favours men over women in almost every facet of life.
It tells the story of Kim Ji-Young, who grows up in South Korea and slowly comes to realise that she is at a disadvantage in almost everything she does simply because she was born female. Her younger brother gets special treatment by her parents (extra food and his own room), she’s sexually harassed at school by her male classmates (but is expected to put up with it because that’s just what boys do), she gets overlooked for promotion at work despite being a dedicated and conscientious employee, she’s expected to give up everything for her husband when she marries — you get the idea.
The easy-to-read narrative is dotted with footnotes relating to gender inequality in Korea — for instance, statistical information on the sex ratio imbalance at birth (116.5 boys born to 100 girls in 1990), and the ways in which women do odd jobs on the side to make money as well as raising children, running households and looking after elderly family members — which lends the story real authenticity.
I found Kim Ji-young, Born 1982 a gripping story, easily read in a day, but I’m not sure it told me anything I didn’t already know. For many teenage girls and young women, however, this novel would be the perfect introduction to feminism. It’s an important and powerful read.
‘The Spill’ by Imbi Neeme
Fiction – paperback; Viking; 336 pages; 2020. Review copy courtesy of the publisher
Before The Spill was published, Imbi Neeme’s manuscript won the Penguin Literary Prize — and it’s easy to see why. This is a gripping tale of two sisters, Nicole and Samantha, whose lives go separate ways following an incident in their childhood (a car accident on a remote road in Western Australia) and who later struggle to reconcile their differences — in temperament, in outlook and the ways in which they see their divorced parents — as adults.
The story, which is largely set in Perth, is told in such an original and ambitious way — vignettes from the past interweaved with the present day, told in alternate chapters from each sister’s perspective — that it’s hard to believe this is the work of a debut novelist. The writing is assured and the characters flesh-and-blood real.
In its portrayal of alcoholism, Neeme shies away from stereotypes or cliches, presenting the disease and its impact on others in all its messy, complicated detail. She does much the same for the relationship between sisters, for Nicole and Samantha are tied together forever but love and loathe each other in myriad different ways. There is jealousy and anger, hurt and regret, misunderstanding and confusion on almost every page. Yet this is not a maudlin story. There are many laughs and witty asides — often at the expense of stepmothers that come into their lives at various times — dotted throughout.
I thoroughly enjoyed being in the company of this tricky and tangled family. It will be very interesting to see what Imbi Neeme comes up with next…
13 thoughts on “Three Quick Reviews: Tanya Bretherton, Cho Nam-ju & Imbi Neeme”
The Killing Streets sounds excellent! I agree with you about Kim Jiyoung, I found it interesting, but not groundbreaking.
I think I was just too old for the Kim Jiyoung book to really make an impact, but I imagine that if you are a teenage girl / young woman it would resonate a lot more.
Yes, particularly if you didn’t know a lot about that culture. Not that I know alot, but I was aware of most of what I came across in the book.
Kim Ji-young, Born 1982 does sound interesting, just to read about a different culture even if the ideas aren’t shocking to some of us more seasoned feminists.
And when is AWW2020 taking place? I have a Virago book set aside for Brona’s AusLitMonth in November; is it over by then?
AWW2020 runs for the entire calendar year, so it’s not too late.
Hey Liz, go here: https://australianwomenwriters.com/
to join the Challenge – then follow the menu to ‘Link your review’, for any books you read by Australian women authors. Their listing of early books available online is great too. Then you can start ‘saving up’ for my week in January – Aust women writers 1920-1960.
LikeLiked by 2 people
I want to keep up with new WA fiction. It’s frustrating because Crow Books (same owner as New Editions, Fremantle) doesn’t have an Australian let alone a Western Australian section. I’ll put The Spill on order until I’m unquarantined.
It’s set in WA but I think the author lives in Melbourne. I assume she grew up in Perth.