2018 Miles Franklin Literary Award, Australia, Australian Women Writers Challenge, Author, AWW2018, Book review, Catherine McKinnon, dystopian, Fiction, Fourth Estate, historical fiction, literary fiction, Literary prizes, Publisher, Setting

‘Storyland’ by Catherine McKinnon

Storyland by Catherine McKinnon

Fiction – Kindle edition; Fourth Estate; 400 pages; 2017. Review copy courtesy of the publisher.

I read Catherine McKinnon’s Storyland about a month before it was longlisted for the 2018 Miles Franklin Literary Award. I’ve been in two minds about reviewing it, because it’s not available outside of Australia*  — which makes it frustrating for those of you in the rest of the world who’d actually like to read it — but I’m hoping the prize listing might change that situation, for this is a superb book deserving of a wide (international) audience.

Set on the banks of Lake Illawarra in New South Wales, Storyland is essentially a fictionalised history of Australia, spanning four centuries. Its focus is very much on how people are shaped by the environments in which they live and vice versa — or, as one of the characters explains in the first chapter, “The land is a book waiting to be read. Learn to read it and you will never go hungry”.

It’s also a timely warning about how we treat the land and the indigenous people who know it best.

‘See that lake there,’ Uncle Ray says, looking along the side of his house to the water. ‘That was here before any of us, and the creek that runs down from the mountain into the lake, that was here too, and the mountain, and the trees, and the birds. We’re part of their story, not the other way around.’ ‘Like they were here first,’ I say. ‘You got it, like they were here first,’ Uncle Ray says. ‘But it’s our job to look after all this land around here. If we don’t, bad things can happen.’

Unusual structure

Many of the reviews I have read online compare it to David Mitchell’s Cloud Atlas — a novel I thought showy and pretentious — but the only real similarity is the structure, for McKinnon’s tale weaves together five interlinking stories, from the late 18th century through to 2717 and then goes backwards in time to the beginning.

All the characters live on the same tract of land but at different time periods, a clever device that allows the author to show how development and progress changes a place, not always for the better.

The time periods and characters are:

  • 1796: Will Martin, a 15-year-old cabin boy, onboard the Tom Thumb with real life explorers Matthew Flinders and George Bass when they discover Lake Illawarra, a large coastal lagoon, about 100km south of Sydney, which forms the setting for the rest of the novel.
  • 1822, Hawker: a desperate ex-convict, who commits a horrendous crime against a local indigenous woman.
  • 1900, Lola: a headstrong young woman who runs a dairy farm with her brother and sister, both of whom have indigenous blood and are subjected to horrific racist abuse and violence when a local girl goes missing.
  • 1998, Bel: a 10-year-old girl, who spends one carefree summer rafting on the lagoon with two neighbourhood boys and then gets caught up in a dispute between a violent man and his girlfriend.
  • 2033 & 2717, Nada: a woman whose world begins to crumble apart in a chilling — but believable — dystopian view of the future.

Recurring themes

Throughout each of the five narrative threads, there are recurring motifs and landmarks — the lake, the shoreline, an ancient fig tree and a stone axe — which helps tie the stories together, and many of the characters are related across the generations. It’s fun trying to spot the connections.

But what really marks this novel as an exceptional one is McKinnon’s eloquent and haunting prose. She’s at her best when she describes landscapes and our connection to particular places, as the following quote demonstrates:

Darkness settles on the forest that runs alongside the field. Cornhusks quiver in the cooling breeze. In this place the heat of the day runs into a noisy night full of jumping beasts with luminous eyes. Here, the night does not entomb the earth, instead it breathes alive ghostly shadows, as if the buried are rising up.

Thematically, there’s a lot going on, including environmental destruction, racism and fear of the Other — just to name a few. I loved its subtle exploration of these issues and its examination of the stories that tie us to the land. The message, it would seem, is that the land (and nature) will outlive us all, but we need to learn to live according to its rules. It will always be here, even if we are not. We mistreat it at our peril.

Down through the trees I see the roof of our home. But what makes a home? Not wood, not bricks; safety, surely. The year that has just passed, all the news reports, protests, referendums, were about national security, or about individual safety, but as if the threat was elsewhere. Yet the biggest danger came from our home itself, only we didn’t know what our home was. We thought it was bricks and mortar, but a home is more than that, it is land and sea and sky.

For other reviews of this novel, please see Bill’s at The Australian LegendLisa’s at ANZ LitLovers and Sue’s at Whispering Gums.

This is my 2nd book for the Miles Franklin Literary Award 2018 and my 12th for #AWW2018

* I scored my copy from the publisher who pitched it to me when it was released last year. I was sent an e-copy but this got lost somehow when I switched to a new Kindle in the summer and I only rediscovered it lurking in the Cloud quite recently. Apologies to the publisher for my tardiness in reviewing!

19 thoughts on “‘Storyland’ by Catherine McKinnon”

  1. Thanks for the link kimbofo and for your great review. I r eally enjoyed it and am surprised it’s not appearing on more award lists. Not enough promotion perhaps. I love the cover too.


    1. You’re welcome, Sue. It’s a great book…a proper literary page turner. I wonder why it’s not appearing on the award lists; it deserves to be lauded.


  2. Thanks for the mention, Kim, and yes, it’s a lovely book.
    I wonder if the fact that the publisher sent you an e-copy means that they want to launch it in the UK market? Fingers crossed, eh?


    1. I wish that were the case but they contacted me after my interview appeared in Books + Publishing magazine (I got lots of publishers emailing me off the back of that). I have, however, told Jane Aiken, the publisher at Gallic Books / Aardvark Bureau about Storyland because she’s always on the lookout for Australian / NZ books to publish. She saw my review of Salt Creek and lo and behold she published it in the UK and it was named Times Book of the Year! How awesome is that 🤗😊

      Liked by 1 person

  3. Thanks from me too. Storyland fell off my prizes radar after I read Terra Nullius (Claire Coleman) but I’m glad to be reminded how well written it is. It’s an interesting concept to have a novel as stories bound together principally by place, something we are learning from Indigenous culture I think.


  4. Somehow I’ve missed this book… not sure why but it sounds fantastic.
    I was tempted to launch into the Miles Franklin longlist but was a bit weary after my Stella reading, so I’m waiting to see what makes the shortlist this week (I’ve only read The Life to Come but have a few more on the TBR list).


    1. I somehow seem to have about 75% of the longlist in my TBR, which is a first for me (that trip back home in March helped, I think) so I hope to read as many as I can off the longlist and definitely everything on the shortlist. Hope you get to read this one. It’s a bit of a page turner, actually, and while it deals with big themes/issues it’s not heavy: I zipped through it in a couple of days!


  5. This sounds wonderful. And I freely admit to being drawn in by that cover (tree covers!). I know it won’t be available for a while, but when it is eventually, I’ll see it and remember your recommendation!


    1. Well, I’m slightly obsessed with trees, Naomi, so understand why you would love this cover. I really hope it gets to be published in Canada given a lot of Australian history mirrors yours.

      Liked by 1 person

  6. Count me in the camp of people frustrated because this sounds really intriguing, particularly the 1900 and 2033 sections. The prices for used copies on Amazon are too steep for me at the moment. Hopefully, a publisher outside of Australia will pick it and publish it.


    1. I’m hoping Gallic Press / Aardvark might pick it up here st some point. I suspect the Australian publishers think the themes in it won’t translate/resonate with an international audience but I think they’re fairly universal: it’s about treatment of indigenous peoples and environmental destruction.

      Liked by 1 person

  7. This sounds excellent – fingers crossed for a UK release. I’m pleased you think it different to Cloud Atlas – I thought I was the only person who didn’t get on with that novel (and I generally like David Mitchell). Beautiful cover too!


I'd love to know what you think, so please leave a comment below

Fill in your details below or click an icon to log in:

WordPress.com Logo

You are commenting using your WordPress.com account. Log Out /  Change )

Facebook photo

You are commenting using your Facebook account. Log Out /  Change )

Connecting to %s

This site uses Akismet to reduce spam. Learn how your comment data is processed.