Fiction – paperback; Bitter Lemon Press; 346 pages; 2020. Translated from the Japanese by Alison Watts.
The Aosowa Murders by Riku Ondo turns the normal conventions of the crime novel on its head. Featuring multiple voices and multiple time frames, the story does not have a neat ending. It leaves the reader with more questions than answers. I finished it a week ago and I am still trying to process what happened.
Death by poison
The central focus of the story is a devastating mass murder in which 17 people (including six children) are poisoned and die agonising deaths at a family celebration in an impressive villa by the sea. The prime suspect is the family’s beautiful and bewitching blind daughter, Hisako, the only family member spared death, but why would she want to kill the loved ones who have given her such a comfortable and “normalised” life?
But The Aosowa Murders is not really a whodunnit because it emerges that another suspect — a young courier who delivered the drinks which were laced with poison — confessed to the crime in a suicide note he left behind when he hanged himself.
Instead, this novel is really about the long-lasting impact of such a horrendous crime on those directly affected by it, including the police who carried out the investigation, those who knew the family well (they were prominent doctors and ran a health clinic) and the local community.
It’s told retrospectively, several decades after the crime, and is as much about a young university student, Makiko, a childhood friend of Hisako’s who wrote a best-selling fictionalised account of what happened, as it is about the actual event and its aftermath.
The book is structured around a series of testimonies in which the interviewer remains absent, so you are never quite sure what the questions are or who is asking them. This lends a one-sided dimension to each chapter, but this multi-voiced approach allows the reader to put together a narrative in his or her head, joining the dots and solving the crime without anything being spelt out by the author herself.
This makes for a challenging read, but it’s a refreshing take on the crime novel. It’s almost as if you become the detective and with each passing chapter you gather more “evidence”, some of which is pivotal to the crime and some of which is irrelevant — and the fun is trying to determine which is which.
It’s an excellent portrait of contemporary Japan, its manners and morals, but I think the biggest (and most important) question it raises is this: how do you make sense of a terrible crime if you don’t understand the motive behind it?
If you like books that make you think, then The Aosowa Murders is a good one to tackle, but if you prefer your crime stories to be relatively straightforward with all the loose ends tied up by the end, then this is probably not for you.
The Aosawa Murders won the 59th Mystery Writers of Japan Award for Best Novel and was selected by the New York Times as one of the most notable books of 2020. Lizzy liked it too.
This is my 3rd book for #BIPOC2021, which is my plan to read more books by black, Indigenous and people of colour over the next year, and it is my 2nd book for #TBR21 in which I’m planning to read 21 books from my TBR between 1 January and 31 May 2021. I also read this as part of Dolce Bellezza’s Japanese Literature Challenge 14. You can find out more about the challenge, which runs from 1 January to 31 March 2021, here.
15 thoughts on “‘The Aosawa Murders’ by Riku Onda”
Sounds very intriguing- added it to my list!
It *is* intriguing, Kate, and the kind of book that would benefit from a second reading. I’m still not sure I’ve figured it all out.
The fact that it doesn’t have a neat ending is appealing – I often find that crime and suspense can feel formulaic toward the end.
Agree… sometimes the need to wrap everything up neatly seems false and rushed. And let’s face it, that’s not how crime cases work in real life.
LikeLiked by 1 person
I’d love to read more Japanese literature and this encourages me to do so. An interesting review, thank you.
Thanks for your comment, Julie. I love Japanese literature, though much of what I’ve read has been Japanese crime. All the Japanese lit I’ve reviewed over the years is here: https://readingmattersblog.com/tag/japanese-literature/
LikeLiked by 1 person
I’ll keep an eye out for this – although I love a whodunnit I also love a whydunnit! 😀
It’s an unusual mix of whodunnit, whydunnit and howdunnit!
LikeLiked by 1 person
This is intriguing me though since I am useless at spotting the villain even in a straightforward crime novel I would probably fail miserably at playing the detective when reading this one.
Well, you’re basically told up front who the villain is… what you’re trying to find out is the how and the why. I didn’t mention in my review that a cryptic clue is left at the scene, so it’s trying to figure out what that might mean, but a large part of the novel focuses on the book that was written about the case: why was it written and what did the author find out?
I’m slowly reading more Japanese fiction. I like the idea of seeing ordinary Japanese life as well as something different from the usual violent crime/clues/action/resolution format.
Wow – this sounds super compelling.